IllustrationPhoto: cattle grazing below a mesa under a storm sky, used here as an illustration. Nothing in this photo is connected to any mutilation case. Photo by Austin Sullivan on Pexels.
What's documented: What sheriffs, state police and the FBI recorded, what the New Mexico project and state veterinary labs found, and what the 2019 and 2023 investigators have said in public.
What's claimed: That the animals were killed and cut up by aliens, by a secret government program, or by cults. Those are claims made by some ranchers, researchers and writers. None has been backed by evidence that an investigating agency accepted.
Status: Explained, according to the official record, for the 1970s New Mexico wave. Unsolved for the recent Oregon and Texas cases, with no cause named and no evidence pointing to UFOs.
Last checked: November 18, 2026, against the sources listed below.
What is cattle mutilation?
The term covers a recurring scene. A rancher finds a cow, bull or horse dead in a pasture. Some soft tissue is gone. The edges of the wounds look straight. There's little or no blood on the ground, no sign of a struggle and, often, no tracks. To the person who finds it, the carcass doesn't look like the work of a coyote.
That last impression is the whole question. Everyone agrees on what the scene looks like. The argument is about what made it, and it's an argument between people who saw the carcass from a few feet away and people who cut into it on a necropsy table.
Where did the UFO link start? The 1967 "Snippy" case
The first case to be tied to flying saucers was a horse. In September 1967, near Alamosa in Colorado's San Luis Valley, a three-year-old Appaloosa mare stabled on the Harry King Ranch was found dead about a quarter-mile from the ranch house with the flesh stripped from her head and neck, according to the Denver Public Library's account of the case. Witnesses described no blood, clean edges and dark patches nearby that they took for exhaust marks.
The press named her "Snippy." Her name was actually Lady; Snippy was her sire, as the Pueblo Chieftain and later accounts noted. The story went national in October 1967 under headlines about flying saucers. The University of Colorado UFO study for the Air Force, the Condon Committee, looked into it and, as later summaries of its file report, found no evidence that the death had any abnormal cause. That pattern, a dramatic first account followed by a dull official answer that never catches up with it, repeats through the rest of this story.
What did the FBI and police do in the 1970s?
Reports multiplied across the western and plains states in the mid-1970s. In New Mexico, they clustered in Rio Arriba County, where state police officer Gabe Valdez investigated cases around Dulce and came to believe a covert government program was behind them.
The FBI's file on the subject is public in the FBI Vault under "Animal Mutilation." Its position, as recorded at a conference Senator Harrison Schmitt convened in Albuquerque on April 20, 1979, was that the Justice Department had given it authority to investigate only mutilations on Indian lands, according to Weight of Evidence's summary of that FBI file. That's a jurisdiction rule, not a finding. Most cases happened on private ranches, which put them with sheriffs and state police.
What did Operation Animal Mutilation find?
The closest thing to a full investigation came next. The district attorney of New Mexico's First Judicial District got a federal Law Enforcement Assistance Administration grant of $44,170 and ran a project from May 28, 1979, to May 27, 1980. Its director was Kenneth Rommel Jr., a retired FBI special agent. His June 1980 report is titled Operation Animal Mutilation.
What the report says it did:
- Reviewed 90 New Mexico cases reported before the project began, from Livestock Board files, state police cases and press accounts.
- Logged 27 more incidents during the project year and personally examined 15 of them at the scene, per the report's case chapter.
- Wrote to every state governor and to veterinarians at state diagnostic labs, including Kansas State, Missouri, Montana, South Dakota State and Texas A&M.
What it concluded, in Rommel's words: in each of the 25 project-year cases reported as mutilations, "the rough jagged nature of the incisions together with the evidence at the scene clearly indicates that the carcass was damaged by predators and/or scavengers." Of the 117 New Mexico reports since 1975, he wrote, "I have not found one single case which, after careful scrutiny of available evidence, could be confirmed as a 'classic mutilation.'"
The vets he quoted said the same. "Many of the scavengers make a clean cut as might be done by a surgeon with a very sharp knife," L. D. Kintner of the University of Missouri wrote. Texas A&M's William Sippel wrote that his lab had "found no evidence of mutilation by humans" in the specimens it received.
That's the official conclusion. It didn't persuade everyone. Valdez and many ranchers rejected it, and the report itself is mostly available today through a transcription on the RR0 research archive rather than a library copy, which researchers who use it have noted.
How can scavengers leave "surgical" cuts?
The report's answer comes down to four ordinary things.
- Which parts go first. The tongue, eyes, lips, udder, genitals and anus are the softest, most exposed tissue on a carcass with a thick hide. Those are the parts scavengers reach first, and the same parts that show up on every "classic mutilation" list.
- What a cut looks like from six feet away. Beaks and small teeth can leave edges that look straight at a distance. Rommel wrote that only a microscope can settle it: a blade cuts hair follicles straight across.
- Where the blood goes. After death, blood settles to the low side of the body and clots. Flies and scavengers take what's on the surface. A carcass can look "drained" without anything having been drained.
- Time. In an experiment the report cites, deputies in Washington County, Arkansas, watched a calf that had just died for more than 30 hours in September 1979. By the end, its tongue and an eye were gone, the anus was "cored" and little blood was visible. The culprits were blowflies, skunks and buzzards, still feeding when the last photos were taken.
The report also tackles the "even scavengers avoided it" claim. Some diseases, such as water belly, leave a carcass that scavengers won't touch, according to a Nebraska agriculture official quoted in it.
What happened in Oregon in 2019?
In late July 2019, five registered Hereford bulls were found dead on Silvies Valley Ranch in Harney County, Oregon, two on July 30 and three more on July 31, the Capital Press reported. Their tongues and genitals were gone.
The lead investigator, Harney County Sheriff's Deputy Dan Jenkins, didn't blame scavengers. "The parts were definitely cut out with a sharp blade," he told the Capital Press. "They were cut out by at least one person." He also said a metal detector found no bullets, and that a necropsy wasn't possible because the bulls were found after the window when one would have been useful. That second point matters. The one test that could have settled how the bulls died wasn't done.
NPR reported in October 2019 that the ranch offered a $25,000 reward, that Jenkins was getting calls blaming aliens, and that the FBI wouldn't confirm or deny any involvement. In July 2026, KTVZ reported that the case was still unsolved and that, judging from Jenkins's earlier public interviews, there were no new leads. Jenkins is now the Harney County sheriff.
What happened in Texas in 2023?
In April 2023, the Madison County Sheriff's Office posted that a six-year-old longhorn-cross cow had been found dead along Texas State Highway OSR with the hide removed from one side of its mouth and its tongue gone. Five more cattle were found in similar shape along the same road into Brazos and Robertson counties, each in a different pasture and herd. On two, the sheriff's office said, "a circular cut was made removing the anus and the external genitalia."
The sheriff's office reported no struggle, no tracks and no blood. It also passed on what ranchers told it: that "no predators or birds would scavenge the remains" for several weeks.
One piece of lab evidence did come back. KBTX reported on April 24, 2023, that a postmortem on a cow in Robertson County pointed to pneumonia as the cause of death, though it didn't explain the missing parts. By then seven cattle had been found. As of an April 2026 report, the case was still open with no suspect, and Madison County Investigator Carly Foster said "no definitive cause or responsible party has been identified."
Where do UFOs come into it?
Mostly through stories, not records. Snippy set the template in 1967. Writer Linda Moulton Howe revisited that case and many later ones in her 1989 book An Alien Harvest, which made the alien explanation popular. In Utah, the Sherman family told the Deseret News in 1996 that cattle had been killed or gone missing on what's now called Skinwalker Ranch; the Uintah County sheriff's records clerk told the paper her office hadn't received reports of UFOs or cattle mutilations in recent memory, as our Skinwalker Ranch briefing sets out.
Folklorists read the whole pattern as a modern legend. Bill Ellis traced how the explanations moved from cults to government tests to aliens in "Cattle Mutilation: Contemporary Legends and Contemporary Mythologies" (Contemporary Legend, 1991). Daniel Kagan and Ian Summers's 1984 book Mute Evidence went through reports nationwide and, according to the Encyclopedia.com summary, found them built on poor observation and rumor.
What none of these sources has is a sighting tied by evidence to a dead animal. The Air Force's Project Blue Book and today's Pentagon office, explained in our AARO briefing, deal with things seen in the sky. We found no official UAP report that links a sighting to a livestock death.
Cases and findings, side by side
| Case | Where and when | What was reported | What investigators found |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Snippy" (Lady) | Alamosa, Colo., Sept. 1967 | Head and neck stripped, no blood, "exhaust" marks | Condon Committee: no evidence of an abnormal cause |
| New Mexico wave | 1975 to 1980, 117 reports | Soft tissue removed, "surgical" cuts | Operation Animal Mutilation: predators and scavengers, no confirmed "classic" case |
| Arkansas test | Washington County, Sept. 1979 | Deputies watched a fresh carcass for 30+ hours | Tongue, eye and anus gone to blowflies, skunks and buzzards |
| Silvies Valley Ranch | Harney County, Ore., July 2019 | Five bulls, tongues and genitals removed | Deputy: cut by a person with a blade; no necropsy; unsolved |
| TX-OSR cattle | Madison, Brazos, Robertson counties, Tex., April 2023 | Tongues and hide removed, no scavenging reported | One necropsy: pneumonia; no cause for the injuries; open |
What's still open
Two different things are true at once, and it helps to keep them apart.
The big 1970s wave, in the one state that paid for a real study, came back as natural death plus scavengers. That study is old, and it couldn't examine every case, but nobody has produced a newer study that overturns it.
Some recent cases don't fit easily. In Oregon, an experienced deputy said the bulls were cut with a blade. In Texas, the sheriff's office passed on ranchers' reports that nothing scavenged the carcasses for weeks. Those are observations by credible people, and we report them as that. They aren't lab findings, and in Oregon no necropsy was done. If a person did this, it's a crime with no suspect. Neither case has produced evidence of anything from the sky.
If you see something in the sky you can't identify, our guide to how to report a UAP sighting covers where reports go, and our briefing on UFO sightings covers how many get explained. A dead animal is a matter for the county sheriff and a vet, ideally within a day, before the evidence is gone.
Sources
- FBI Records: The Vault, Animal Mutilation
- Kenneth M. Rommel Jr., Operation Animal Mutilation (June 1980), Conclusions and Recommendations, RR0 transcription
- Weight of Evidence: Operation Animal Mutilation (Rommel report) case file, with FBI file summaries
- Denver Public Library Special Collections: UFOs and a Horse Called Snippy
- Pueblo Chieftain: Beating a dead horse: 'Snippy' lively topic (December 17, 2006)
- Wikipedia: Mutilation of "Snippy" the horse
- Capital Press: Investigation continues in death, mutilation of bulls (August 7, 2019)
- NPR: 'Not One Drop Of Blood': Cattle Mysteriously Mutilated In Oregon (October 8, 2019)
- KTVZ: Cattle mutilations in Central and Eastern Oregon remain a mystery for ranchers (July 2, 2026)
- Click2Houston: Law enforcement investigating deaths, mutilation of cattle in Madison, Robertson, Brazos Counties (April 19, 2023)
- NBC News: Six cattle that died mysteriously in Texas had their tongues removed, authorities say (April 2023)
- KBTX: New information shared Monday about cow deaths in the area (April 24, 2023)
- Hoodline: Back-road cow mutilations still spook three Texas counties (April 2026)
- Bill Ellis, "Cattle Mutilation: Contemporary Legends and Contemporary Mythologies," Contemporary Legend 1 (1991)
- Encyclopedia.com: Cattle Mutilations
Questions people ask
What is cattle mutilation?
Cattle mutilation is the name for livestock found dead with soft parts missing, such as the tongue, eyes, udder or genitals, and wounds that look surgically clean, often with little blood and no tracks. Reports date from a Colorado horse in 1967 and a wave across western states in the 1970s.
Did the FBI investigate cattle mutilations?
Only in a limited way. The FBI's Animal Mutilation file shows it said in 1979 that it could investigate only cases on Indian lands. The main study was New Mexico's Operation Animal Mutilation (1979 to 1980), a federally funded project run by retired FBI agent Kenneth Rommel Jr.
What causes cattle mutilation?
In the New Mexico study, natural death followed by scavengers. Kenneth Rommel's 1980 report found jagged, scavenger-made wounds in every case it examined and no confirmed 'classic mutilation.' Some recent cases, like Oregon's in 2019, are blamed by investigators on a person with a blade and remain unsolved.
Are cattle mutilations still happening?
Yes, reports continue. Five bulls were found mutilated on an Oregon ranch in July 2019, and six or seven cattle along Texas Highway OSR in April 2023. As of 2026 reporting, both cases were still open with no suspect named.
What happened to Snippy the horse?
In September 1967 a three-year-old Appaloosa mare, actually named Lady, was found dead near Alamosa, Colorado, with the flesh stripped from her head and neck. Press reports tied it to flying saucers. The Condon Committee, as later summaries report, found no evidence of an abnormal cause.
Are cattle mutilations linked to UFOs?
No investigation has linked one to a UFO. The connection comes from press coverage of the 1967 Snippy case and from writers such as Linda Moulton Howe. Official and veterinary reviews pointed to scavengers, disease or, in some cases, people.
Corrections: if something here is wrong, tell us and we'll fix it and say so on this page.